About:

Our blog covers topics of importance to anyone interested in buying or selling a home in the metro-Warren/Detroit area.

Categories


A Mortgage Meltdown Quiz

You have been reading about the mortgage meltdown and seeing daily news reports about the record number of foreclosures. Mortgage lenders are dropping like flies. Even large companies such as Countrywide Mortgage are feeling the crunch, having to borrow billions of dollars to keep their doors open. Based on what you have read, heard, and seen in the media, maybe you feel as though you have a pretty good grasp of what is going on and what caused it, but how much do you really know?

To find out how savvy you really are about this mortgage meltdown, take the following single-question quiz:

Why have so many mortgage lenders gone out of business?

A. Homeowners are unable to make their payments.
B. Massive amounts of real estate and mortgage fraud.

If you are among the multitudes of the ill-informed, you probably chose A. And if this were the 1950s, perhaps you would have been correct. Back in the 1950s when banks loaned money directly to people who were unable to repay the debt, the banks took a direct hit to their bottom line. They felt the pain.

In the current system, most banks rely on brokers to originate the mortgage loans. These brokers typically have loan officers who work for them and are in charge of selling loans to consumers, helping the consumers fill out their loan applications, and performing other tasks to expedite the loan process. Loan originators receive a commission for every loan that’s approved, and because they are lending someone else’s money, they take on risk only indirectly.

When someone borrows $300,000 to purchase a home, for example, the broker receives 2 points at closing for a total of $6,000. They then package the loan with other loans and sell it to the market at 104 percent or $312,000. In this case, the originator just “earned” $18,000 off the mortgage loan-the $6,000 commission plus the $12,000 markup.

When bad loans are traced back to mortgage fraud, misrepresentations, and misdeeds, originators takes a double hit. They are forced to buy back the bad loans, and the lender cuts off access to future transactions. With huge chunks of money flowing out and little or no money flowing in, the mortgage originator is forced to close up shop. That is what is currently happening and why we are now seeing a mortgage meltdown.

When interest rates were low and housing prices were soaring, mortgage fraud was rampant, but the problem remained hidden because homeowners were awash in equity. Credit was easy to get, and mortgage brokers and loan officers made it even easier. If an applicant couldn’t qualify for a particular loan, the loan officer would simply encourage the applicant to fudge the numbers or would fudge the numbers on the applicant’s behalf. If a home buyer wanted a larger loan to cash out some money at closing, you could always find an applicant to accommodate-inflating the appraisal to make the property appear to be worth more than it really was. Loan officers were tripping over each other to approve risky loans and nab their commissions.

MILA, a subprime wholesale lender that was based in Mountlake Terrace, Washington shut down during the spring of 2007, primarily due to the fact that its loan officers were responsible for huge numbers of fraudulent loans. Several employees who refused to go on the record reported that they passed along proof of fraud committed by at least one of the company’s loan officers. This person made so much money for the company that instead of firing its employee, MILA relocated and promoted the person.

Now that the housing market is in a slump, it’s as though the water has been drained out of the pond, and now we can see what is at the bottom… a whole lot of muck.

5 Comments »

  1. Ralph,

    You have absolutely no idea what your talking about do you? Such a fundamental misunderstanding of loans and th esecondary market.

    When someone borrows $300,000 to purchase a home, for example, the broker receives 2 points at closing for a total of $6,000. They then package the loan with other loans and sell it to the market at 104 percent or $312,000. In this case, the originator just “earned” $18,000 off the mortgage loan-the $6,000 commission plus the $12,000 markup.

    Brokers don’t sell loans-ever.

    Your a cheap pimp who obviously has to rent an extra room to fit your ego in.

    Do your research before you espouse knowledge of something that you clearly don’t understand.

    Good luck spreading misinformation.

    Comment by Jeff Jennings — November 16, 2007 @ 1:22 am

  2. Mr. Roberts,

    I just read your article in Realty Times and feel that your cited example of an originators/brokers earnings on a $300,000 loan at $18,000 is distorted well beyond any measure of reason and that it slams the entire mortgage industry as a whole, and without exception. Shame, Shame! Granted there are those that were consumed by greed but this is not the norm….unfortunately to many people will believe what they read. I am 60 yrs old and this industry has been my career and my passion for 2/3’s of my life. If I made the money that you suggest I would have retired 20 years ago and be sipping on Margueritas in the Bahamas for several months of each year. In fact, I have never made even ½ of what you suggest on any single loan. As a Real Estate Broker/Agent on that same $300K sale I suppose that you would have no guilt in walking away with a $12-21,000 commission check as you earned every penny of it! Blanket statements such as these are most unprofessional….in my opinion!

    Comment by Ron Withers — November 16, 2007 @ 6:45 am

  3. Oh noes, the evil mortgage industry makes 18,000 on a loan! Let’s not forget the Real Estate Agents that get an average of 7% combined, or $21,000 for the sticking a sign in the yard and putting the property in the MLS. But that kind of money would NEVER lead a blessed real estate agent to commit fraud, now would it?

    Before you say “A Real Estate Agent does more than stick a sign in the yard, you don’t know what you are talking about” realize that the same thing applies to this appalling post.

    Comment by Chuck — November 16, 2007 @ 11:53 am

  4. Ralphy, you sir, are a Donkey.

    We demand a retraction. Don’t just ignore the negative reponses (in mass) you received from your ill informed article.

    How’s your classes on “Flipping”? I guess that never really played a part in all this mess, huh?

    Comment by Mortgage Guy — November 19, 2007 @ 5:35 pm

  5. This is fascinating stuff, made more so by the cloak-and-dagger style of the banks themselves. Even now, it’s hard to say who’s doing what or lending what or borrowing what from whom, given the many layers of secrecy.

    There’s an interesting bit of mortgage ‘detective work’ at this Google Answers page:

    https://answers.google.com/answers/threadview?id=225756
    Mortgage and refinance loans

    The researcher does a nice job of using obscure sources of data and peeking under the covers of bank lending practices.

    David

    Comment by David — February 11, 2008 @ 7:34 pm

RSS feed for comments on this post.

Leave a comment